Survivor: Old versus Young with all Returning Players

With the verge of a season based on two different generations fighting, I thought that I would do another one of my hypothetical casts for a season this time putting old returning players against young returning players. I might exclude players from Panama and Nicaragua simply because they have already played a season like that before. Panama wasn’t too much like that, I’ll admit, simply because of the tribe divisions from episode 2 onward. But that doesn’t mean that they should do it again. Also, due to how people keep ageing, I probably will have to pass on some of the older people from earlier seasons so if they are among the older contestants now, then I might have to include them. But they can’t be too old or I know that they won’t be cast in seasons like this anyways.

Older men I’d cast: Paschal from Marquesas is a pretty interesting man. He fought hard and was eliminated from the game without a single vote ever cast against him. He should return. Gary from Guatemala would be a great player and great choice for returning to play the game again. Plus, at some point they are going to have to bring back a player originally from that season, right? Yau-Man from Fiji and Micronesia is a smart player who knows how to get things done. Tarzan from One World may be a random choice, but he’s the type of crazy person who still makes a good player to watch. Dale from San Juan del Sur is my last pick for the older men.

Older women I’d cast: Teresa from Africa is someone who has to return to the game at some point before she gets too old. Kathy from Marquesas and All-Stars is someone who I feel needs more done with her game so she should return. Gillian from Gabon is very active in the Survivor community so it makes sense that she should return to play the game again. Trish from Cagayan is a wonderful player and she should return again sometime. Carolyn from Worlds Apart is another great contestant who I think she be brought back. Thus ends the list of older players that I’d bring back.

Younger men I’d cast: James from Palau may not be that young, but he is entertaining and it would be a shame if we never see her again. Erik from Micronesia and Caramoan may not be the smartest player, but he’s still someone I feel should play again. Matty from Gabon is a player that I liked and will thus cast on this season. Eddie from Caramoan may have been on the wrong side of the numbers a lot, but he was still a pretty effective player. Spencer from Cagayan and Cambodia is a player who needs more love and I’m casting him on this pretend season of mine.

Younger women I’d cast: Jenna from Borneo and All-Stars may be a bit of a weird choice, but I am still putting her in my cast. Neleh from Marquesas is someone who I really liked the first time and feel should return again. Darrah from Pearl Islands is another player who should return and I’m surprised hasn’t been asked back ever. Eliza from Vanuatu and Micronesia is a player that I really like and feel should return again. Mikayla from South Pacific is my last pick of the younger tribe.

Well, there’s my cast. I would mention alternates, but I don’t feel that such a thing is necessary. Do you like my picks for an all-stars young versus old? Did I miss anyone that you’d think would work better? I just hope that I did a well enough pick. For now, this is Adam Decker, signing off.